Déjà vu

I sometimes think I may be the only person in America who faced  a situation  similar to what Cyprus is going through now; so similar it gives me the creeps.

The morning I heard about the Cypriot tribulations, I told my husband it had the finger of the IMF – International Monetary Fund –  in it.  I still remember vividly how it felt to have our money seized by the government. It doesn’t really matter who the government is; we may call it the European  Central Bank or the  IMF or Cyprus Central Bank; the result  to the common person, who does not have enough money  to maintain an offshore account in the Caribbean or Switzerland, is the same.

Flashback and move south. The year is 1992. After twenty years of military government – which were not bad except the generals in charge did not know anything about Economics and immersed the country is a tsunami of hyperinflation (eight four percent per month and growing) –  the country is electing its president.  Multiply those eight four percent by twelve and you’ll have an astronomical yearly number. Divide those into thirty and you’ll have an idea of how much the money in your pocket devaluated every single day of the month.

Most Americans don’t have a clue of how life is with hyperinflation. I hope we’ll never find out. Maybe one day I’ll write a blog about the chaos of hyperinflation. But I need to prepare myself psychologically for that so for now this blog post will leave inflation out and deal with how Brazil went through and survived a strikingly similar financial chaos as to the one we see developing in Cyprus.  

Back to Brazil’s three decades of military rule (much better than the option – a communist/socialist government), I felt very proud to vote for president for the first time. Fernando Collor de Mello was young and well-spoken, from a wealthy family in North Brazil with a long tradition in politics. In a much smaller scale, the Color de Mello family was to North Brazil what the Kennedys are to America. Fernando Collor de Mello himself had been the governor of the state of Alagoas. His wife was either adored or hated; some found her pretty, some found her weird. For a while Brazil had its first royal couple; Fernando talked about innovations and free trade, open markets, privatization of state-owned giant companies, industrial modernization and public debt reduction.

I was eager to trust Mr. Collor de Mello.   Most of all, I voted for him to keep his opponent out and looking back now I believe a lot of people did the same.  The opponent was a steel union worker and activist  nick named Lula. Short for Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. He sounded angry, furious; he hated capitalism and America. He was going to take land of productive farmers and distribute it to the destitute.  He was going to force families living in big houses to share their homes with poor families from the favelas (Brazilian name for slums). I believed Mr. Lula too, with all my heart. His public speeches made me fear for the future of the country. Who in the international community, in their right mind, would invest one cent in Brazil if a maniac of such proportions was elected? And God knows how desperately Brazil needed foreign investments back then.   

That was the beginning of a populist and useless movement called Sem-Terra – the Landless. Lula’s speeches attracted crowds of people as angry and violent-sounding as he himself. Wherever Lula went, a trail of disorderly conduct followed. In one extreme case, a police officer was murdered in plain day light, in my own southern city, Porto Alegre, by a group of Lula’s sem-terra, armed with knives and scythes, in one of their public protests.  That was also the beginning of President Lula’s struggle to become Brazil’s president, which he achieved not once, but twice, reelected for a second term, in a total of eight years, from 2003 through 2011.

In contrast, Brazil’s royal couple, the Collor de Mellos, sounded nice and polite, refined, well-dressed, well travelled. But I know I would have voted for anyone just to keep Lula away from Brasilia, the Federal Capital. In my ardent wishes to see the country led by a trustworthy, capitalist, educated and experienced president, I voted for Mr. Collor de Mello with a gusto that can only come from needing to trust someone; from wanting to find a good and responsible president for our emerging democracy, so wounded by relentless inflation. 

In 1989 Collor defeated Lula in a two-round presidential race and thirty five million votes. Even for us in the South, far away from Collor’s political activities in North Brazil, he looked, sounded and felt like God-sent. The first democratically elected Brazilian president in almost thirty years would make the battle against hyperinflation the heart and soul of its administration and find a solution to the next impending crisis: Brazil was very close to default in its international loans. As to who was Brazil’s biggest and most powerful creditor back then,  here is where the disheartening similarities with Cyprus begin.

On the very day he took office, President Collor launched the Plano Collor (Collor Plan). The plan’s aim, according to a summary I found in Wikipedia, “was to reduce the money supply by forcibly converting large portions of consumer bank accounts into non-cashable government bonds, while at the same time increasing the printing of money bills, a contradictory measure to combat hyperinflation. (…) All accounts over 50,000 Cruzeiros (about US$1,300 at that time), were frozen for eighteen months. He also proposed freezes in wages and prices, as well as major cuts in government spending. The measures were received unenthusiastically by the people, though many felt that radical measures were necessary to kill the hyperinflation.”

The Collor Plan was released after a series of long and secretly held meetings in Brasilia, between IMF officials and Collor’s finance minister Ms. Zelia Cardoso de Mello (not related to the president by the way). Brazil did not default on its international loan payments. But the entire country woke up poorer one fine Monday morning, with banks closed for days in a row and anxiety levels the height of Rio’s famous Sugar Loaf mount.

In case Wikipedia’s text –  to reduce the money supply by forcibly converting large portions of consumer bank accounts into non-cashable government bonds – confused you, what Color did was to confiscate all bank accounts over 50,000 Cruzeiros (Brazil’s old currency) from both individuals and businesses. It was chaos, as you can imagine. In acute cases that were becoming increasingly more numerous across the country, people committed suicide. It would take another couple of blogs to go over the parade of disasters that took Brazil by storm after Collor released his magic plan. As a result, in order to try to fix the errors, the president and his team of Economists came up with Plano Collor II, which proved ineffective.  Collor’s administration was paralyzed due to the fast deterioration of his image through a succession of corruption accusations, as Wikipedia describes.

On October 2, 1992, President Collor received formal notice from the Brazilian Senate that the Chamber of Deputies had accepted the charges presented against him and that he was now a defendant in a trial of impeachment that the Senate would conduct. According to  Brazil’s Constitution, upon receipt of that notification, Collor’s powers were suspended for 180 days and the vice president became acting president. On December 29, 1992, facing almost certain conviction and removal from office by the Senate, Collor resigned just as the trial was underway, in the last day of the proceedings. Collor’s resignation letter was read by his attorney in the floor of the Senate, and the impeachment trial was adjourned so that the Congress could meet in joint session, first to take formal notice of the resignation and proclaim the office of President vacant, and then to swear-in the Vice-President as President, as required by the Brazilian Constitution. (Source: Wikipedia)

I guess what most historical accounts fail to acknowledge is that Collor and his Finance Minister did not come up with that all by themselves. Removing money from Brazilians’ bank accounts was one of the strategies the IMF required in order to give Brazil the money the country needed.  Brazil was not part of any international community as Cyprus is part of the European Market but just like Cyprus, the money that saved the financial viability of the nation was not coming in at a cheap cost.  

In those pre-globalization days, before the Web, Brazil’s tribulations were not as publicized as Cyprus, but equally painful to its citizens. It would take the country years after Collor’s impeachment to get the hyperinflation under control. Cyprus situation has even more serious repercussions because it sends out waves of fear that other countries in the European Union may be forced to take the same shocking measures – the IMF’s registered mark.

Twenty years after Collor, I still can recognize the IMF’s fingerprints when I see it. Fortunately this time, from a distance. The IMF giveth and the IMF taketh away.

About livlugara

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Déjà vu

  1. Sandra Mann says:

    Fascinating, Livia! I did not know that Brazil went through this although when I visited Brazil in the 80’s the money that was used was cruzeiros and I remember noticing later on that the monetary unit changed (Cruzados??). To most Americans the closest we have come to this is when the stock markets kept losing hundreds of points a few years ago during the mortgage scandals. I can’t even imaging my savings being taken away. Fortunately I don’t deny myself a lot (at least it never felt that way) in order to save. I guess I don’t really trust the future. But I have saved and I would really be sick if it got taken away.

    I hope all is going well for you! Spring is on the way which makes me happy!


    • livlugara says:

      Thank you, Sandy ! Those were very hard days indeed… I feel bad for the people in Cuprus because I remember how betrayed we felt in Brazil. Hopefully the new generations will learn about such episodes only from books and blogs…

    • livlugara says:

      I meant to add in my comment above, about “Cruzados”, Brazil’s currency in the 80’s:
      The oldest currency I remember was Cruzeiro, from the 70’s. When the currency changed from Cruzeiro (Cr$) into Cruzado (Cz$) three zeros were removed, meaning that if you had in your pocket Cr$1,000, after the government changed the currency to Cruzado, you ended up with Cz$1.00 ! That would happen many times between the 80’s and mid 90’s. After the Cruzado, Brazil entered the Cruzado Novo (new Cruzado) era, and cut three zeros more. Later, the country returned to Cruzeiro, cutting no zeros this time. Then Brazil adopted the Cruzeiro Real, again cutting three zeros more. But the best of all would come on July 1st 1994, when the currency changed to the current name, REAL (R$) and 2,750 Cruzeiros Reais (CR$) became equivalent to one Real (R$): CR$2,750 = R$1.00. I don’t even know how we went through all that without losing our heads… All done in the name of fighting Brazil’s hyperinflation…

  2. yahoo.com says:

    Fantastic blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
    I’m planning to start my own blog soon but I’m a little lost
    on everything. Would you advise starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option?
    There are so many options out there that I’m totally confused
    .. Any tips? Cheers!

    • livlugara says:

      I agree; it can be confusing, with so many options floating around. For me the main thing was to keep it simple. I just wanted a place in the Web to write about things and facts and people that inspire me. I did not want anything fancy and complicated that required a lot of planning and designing. I just wanted to write. I wanted the blog to look simple, without any distractions. We already get a lot of that in the Internet… This is where I went to start my blog:
      Just another WordPress.com
      I hope it works for you as well. Thank you for your kind words; for taking the time to leave me a comment!

  3. If you desire to get much from this paragraph then you have to apply such
    techniques to your won weblog.

  4. Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an incredibly
    long comment but after I clicked submit my comment
    didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that
    over again. Anyhow, just wanted to say wonderful blog!

  5. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and
    I in finding It really helpful & it helped me out a lot. I am hoping to give something again and aid others such as you helped me.

  6. Jannie says:

    But if it looks likely that we’ll see refinements of these electronic products are known for treating impotence in men. The Pad
    8’s new camera. No personal insults No section can be difficult for
    programmers of such promotional products companies.
    If you have a 10″ Android tablets.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s